Ask ECESign in
Children's agency in early childhood: Who owns the clock?
Practice

Children's agency in early childhood: Who owns the clock?

Practice · Anne · 10 min read
Published

Think back over last week. What's one thing in your room that is different now because a child made it so? Not something a child picked from options you put out. Something that changed because of them.

Try it on your team. The answers, if they come, are likely to be small and specific: a mud kitchen moved closer to the sandpit because children kept carrying the pots across, a different rest time story because one child kept asking for it. It's a harder question than "are we offering enough choice?", and it gets much closer to what agency means.

The EYLF V2.0 defines agency as being able to make choices and decisions, to influence events and to have an impact on one's world. Choice is only the first part of that. The fuller test is influence: whether anything changes because of what a child says or does. One recent German study found routines and transitions were largely run by adults. Educators can widen agency by sharing control of time, treating babies' signals as views, and telling children what happened to their ideas.

What the EYLF says agency is

The definition is in the glossary of the EYLF V2.0: being able to make choices and decisions, to influence events and to have an impact on one's world. Element 1.2.3 of the National Quality Standard uses almost the same words. It asks that each child's agency is promoted, enabling them to make choices and decisions that influence events and their world.

Both sentences have a second half that tends to get skipped. A child who picks the red cup over the blue one has made a choice. Whether that choice influenced events, or had any impact on their world, is a separate question.

The framework returns to this more than once. Outcome 1 says identity and confidence are built when all children are offered genuine choices, time and opportunity to exercise agency. Time gets its own mention there. Outcome 2 builds children's connection to their world on the idea that they can exert agency in ways that make a difference, and calls that a foundation for civic and democratic participation. That's a lot to rest on a choice of cups.

Why do so many of us treat agency as choice?

Choice photographs well and fits on a planning sheet. It also fits a busy day. You can offer it inside a routine that's already set, with ratios to meet and lunch arriving at 11.30.

Offering real choices is good practice, and the framework asks for it. The problem comes when choice is all there is. Many of the choices in a room come from a menu adults wrote. Adults decide what goes on the shelves, when pack-up happens and which experiences are out today. Children pick from what's on offer. To us that can look like agency. From where the child stands, very little in their world has moved.

Part of the muddle is that researchers don't agree on what agency is either. In a 2019 review in Educational Research Review, Jan Varpanen identified six theoretical resources, or bodies of theory, that early childhood research has drawn on to describe children's agency. When a word is understood in that many ways, teams tend to settle on the one that's easiest to do on a Tuesday.

The clock problem

A study published in 2026 in the Early Childhood Education Journal looked at how children's agency plays out in everyday centre life. In the German state of Rhineland-Palatinate, a 2021 law brought in a formal participation structure, the Kita-Beirat, a council meant to bring everyone with a stake, children among them, into decisions. Researchers observed and talked with children aged three to six, before the change came in and again about a year later. Seventy-eight children took part, and three centres from a wider group of ten were looked at in depth.

A formal structure can give children a way in. But the authors found that what mostly decided whether children actually had a say was the quality of everyday interaction. They traced children's agency to three linked things: power, relationships and what they called space-time. Routines, transitions and the use of space were largely run by adults. Where the pace slowed and control of time was shared, there was more real back-and-forth between children and educators. Explaining why adults made the decisions, one child put it simply: because they are grown.

That's one study in one German state, and the authors say plainly it may not transfer everywhere. Closer to home, ACECQA points the same way. Its information sheet on supporting agency recommends "flexible and unhurried routines" and suggests using children's behaviour rather than the clock as the cue for meal time.

The EYLF itself counts routines as curriculum: it says curriculum encompasses all the interactions, experiences, routines and events, planned and unplanned. Which is uncomfortable, because the clock so often belongs to us. A room can run a play program full of choice and still decide, every day, when play ends. Hand washing and going inside run on the same timetable.

Voice is not enough

In 2007 the children's rights scholar Laura Lundy published a paper in the British Educational Research Journal titled "'Voice' is not enough". Her point was that Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child gives children more than a right to speak. It gives them the right to have their views given due weight, in line with their age and maturity.

Her model breaks that into four parts. Children need space, a safe and inclusive chance to form and share a view. They need voice, meaning help to express it. They need an audience: someone who actually listens. And their views need influence, which means they're acted on where that's appropriate.

In many early childhood settings, the first two come more easily. We hold group times, we ask questions, we write children's ideas on big sheets of butcher's paper. Audience and influence ask more of us, because they mean something has to change.

Babies have views too

The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child is clear that views come before words. In General Comment No. 12 (2009) it notes that research shows children can form views from the youngest age, even before they can express them verbally. It names play, body language, facial expressions, drawing and painting as ways very young children show understanding, choices and preferences, and says those forms of communication need to be recognised and respected.

Picture a baby who turns her head away from the spoon, or a toddler who goes stiff and quiet at the door before outdoor time. Read as views, those signals can change what happens next: a pause, a slower pace, another try in ten minutes. For the youngest children, agency often looks less like choosing and more like being responded to.

A one-week test for your room

This takes very little time and tends to show things a planning meeting won't.

  1. Pick one routine. Lunch, pack-up or the move from inside to outside. Choose the one that feels most rushed.
  2. Keep a five-minute tally. After the routine each day, one educator jots down the decisions in it: when it started, how long it took, what happened when a child wasn't ready. Next to each, note whether an adult or a child made the call.
  3. Check who wrote the menu. For each choice children had, ask who set the options, and whether a child could ever change them.
  4. Run Lundy's four questions. Was there space for a view? Could the child express it, in words or any other way? Did anyone listen? Did anything change?
  5. Hand one thing over, and tell the children. Pick one small decision, such as how pack-up starts, and give it to the children. Afterwards, tell them what happened with their idea, so they see that it counted.

Rest can be part of this too, with care. Regulation 84A requires the approved provider and the nominated supervisor (and, in family day care, the educator) to take reasonable steps to make sure each child's sleep and rest needs are met, having regard to their age, development and individual needs. Your service's sleep and rest policies and procedures set out how, so any change has to work within the regulation and your policies.

The tally fits well into the critical reflection part of your planning cycle. If you'd like to talk a particular routine through, the Knowledge Engine can help you connect it to the EYLF outcomes and Element 1.2.3.

Where this gets hard

Handing over the clock isn't always possible, and sometimes it shouldn't be. Safety, supervision, health and each child's wellbeing come first, and ratios and staffing put real limits on how flexible a day can be. The EYLF puts the two side by side: "Children's agency as well as guidance, care and teaching by families and educators shape children's experiences of becoming." Agency sits alongside adult responsibility.

A team can also tick every box above and still keep the decisions that matter. A vote on the fish's name is lovely, and it costs nothing. The decisions children care about are bigger: how long they get to finish something they're absorbed in, whether a block tower can stay up overnight, whether they can sit out of group time.

Sometimes the honest answer is still no. A child asks to stay outside and today you can't make it work. Agency doesn't mean the answer is always yes. It means the child's view was weighed, and they were told why.

A question to take back

Many rooms could show you a dozen choices in an afternoon. Ask for one thing a child changed and it takes longer. Often the difference is time: the thing educators feel shortest of and, in the German study at least, something adults largely controlled.

So here's the question. If a child in your room could change one thing about how the day runs, what would they change first, and which part of it could you hand over this month?

Sources

Sources checked 2 November 2026. This article is general information about practice. It isn't advice about your service's obligations under the National Law or Regulations.

Keep reading: Intentional teaching in early childhood, What is the EYLF? and The five EYLF outcomes.

Share:FacebookLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Have a specific question?

Ask ECE gives you grounded answers from current Australian ECE frameworks in seconds.

Try Ask ECE free
More from the library · Ask ECE · You Ask. We Answer.